In a time long ago, before there was a World Wide Web, even before there were Personal Computers, "PAL" was the computer for Everyman. It was completely free to everyone, with unlimited round-the-clock access, simple to use, required no special hardware to buy, and the user's anonymity was assured. Here is the story of a wonderful adventure in innovation, whereby MM learns many expensive (but valuable) lessons in business.
The PAL Adventure
After a year of selling cars, I was looking for alternatives. That's when I got a call from a name out of the past.
Dave Shefrin had been the owner/president
of a software company in Hartford, CT who supplied the Accounts Receivable software for the services
we offered on our computer at EDP. But the product didn't have a sales analysis subsystem, and that's what
really sold services was all the neat sales reports you could get. So I wrote the sales software myself in
a couple of days, making it a very generalized package that could do almost anything.
All parameter driven, it was really a report generator, and it worked like a charm.
I gave (as in no money) the software to Dave who then added it to his A/R package. It was
a big hit with his customers. It didn't matter to me that I never saw a dime from it
because I just wrote what was needed, and gave it to those who needed it.
There was no intention to gain from it. It was this spirit that I feel was the Karma behind Dave's call
to me that got the whole magical adventure going.
So now it's several years later, and Dave gets to wondering whatever happened to Michael McCafferty, and gets my
number in San Diego from my previous employer in Chicago (never burn your bridges). He calls me, and asks if I've made my
first million yet. I had to admit I was still quite a bit short of that goal. He announces that he has sold his
software company and was looking to invest in something and was wondering if "I would invent something and he
will back me and we would make a lot of money and have fun, 50/50, ok?"
So what did I have to lose, right? I'm selling Fiats! This was just treading water.
However, since I had gone through this startup
ordeal before, and if I was going to do it again, then I was determined to do it right this time.
So I sat down
with a clean sheet of paper, and made a list of all the things I wanted in an ideal business. The list
looked something like this:
A creative, unique business that has never been done before, ever, anywhere.
No competition. A monopoly.
No receivables.
No physical inventory.
No employees. Run by computers.
No limits. Global, all people, all markets, round the clock.
Massively scalable. Rapid deployment.
Simple. Easy to use, easy to sell.
There were about 13 points on the paper after a lot of thought over many days. The only trouble was that
I still had to invent the business to conform to these constraints. This took 3 months. The result was "PAL", the world's
first completely free, round the clock, anonymous computer service, accessed over ordinary telephone lines,
needing no computer for the user (only a Touch Tone telephone, PC's hadn't been invented yet). The application was a
real-time replacement for the Yellow Pages, along with other free applications to gain traffic. It was,
in fact, a precursor to Google and the World Wide Web that would come along more than 16 years later. Nothing like being
a little ahead of the crowd...
The name PAL was an acronym for "Product & Area Locator" and a take-off on "HAL", the computer
in the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey.
Callers would be greeted with a computer voice: "Hello,
this is PAL, how may I help you?" The caller would reply by touching the keys on the phone that would spell
out the name of a product or service and then their zip code, and PAL would locate the closest listing, speak
the database information (including special offers going on now) and even switch the call, free, if the caller
wanted.
My potential investor Dave was overwhelmed. He thought maybe I would invent a software product (that would
come later) and that the business model and target audience would be clearly defined and something he had
experience with. This PAL stuff was completely beyond his comfort level. He wanted to have proof that such
amazing things could be done with a computer. So I programmed the application on "GEnie", General Electric's
timesharing service, probably the
only online computer service that had a voice response system available for use on the network. When he saw an
early prototype of PAL, he believed that
it was technically feasible, but now he wanted proof that it could be sold. Would businesses really buy such
a new fangled electronic Yellow Pages?
To demonstrate the answer, I put together a group of experienced telemarketers in
a small office in Cardiff-by-the-Sea, California, and we wrote
a script for a one-shot phone presentation aimed at getting Cash Now. The pitch was that we told the prospect
that there were amazing developments happening with computers (never an argument) and that they would be a great
help to business (no argument) and individuals (no argument) and a huge leap in computers for everyone was just
made right here in San Diego and would be released in 3 months to everyone who lived or worked in San Diego.
We told these prospects that they were among the first businesses in San Diego to be contacted to participate
in this wonderful opportunity, and if they
signed up now they would be able to take advantage of introductory special prices, AND they would also be able
to reserve the best of a very limited number of ad spots that their competition would never be able to take over
(as long as they kept paying the bills).
Put another way, we were telling them that this thing had never been done before, and that we were going to do it
in three months, and that we wanted them to sign up Now and we would be out that same day to pick up their
check! That was the outrageous part to me, picking up the check right away. But I deferred to the experience
of our telemarketers. They wanted to get paid, and they were paid commission only, and only on collected funds.
They were experts at getting the money now. It was a beautiful thing to behold.
What made all the difference was the real-time nature of this new advertising medium. It was possible for our
employees to re-program PAL immediately to refer each new advertiser's information in the database. This completely
binary situation, either you are in the database or you are not, coupled with the perception of the very limited
number of ad spots (3). These conditions set a fire under the telemarketers, and their enthusiasm showed in their
sales. Dave was convinced, and now all I had to do was make it happen.
So with the money we raised selling the ads in advance, I bought a computer (Cromemco CPM machine with a 10MB
hard disk drive and 4 modems and a Votrax voice response unit), and programmed the main software in COBOL
myself, and subcontracted a couple of machine language subroutines. What I was asking this little toy
computer to do was way beyond its capabilities, but somehow I got it to work. And finally, the big day
arrived when I had to let the world know that PAL was alive and well, and that the world would never again
be the same.
This was a very big idea, and just before I pulled the trigger on the announcement, I got scared.
I had no idea what the phone company would do when
I announced it, but I knew they wouldn't like it. One of their big profit centers has always been the
Yellow Pages. The phone company could easily squash my little business like a bug, or keep us tied up
in court with injunctions until we gave up, or just cause a lot of line static, and interfere with
the calls. There were plenty of ways they could cause problems, and it worried me a lot. And I struggled long and hard
with the idea of actually notifying them of my idea before I went ahead, but I felt that was
definitely the wrong way to go about it. They would study it forever before I got an answer, and the
answer would probably be NO.
This was one of those times when it would be "Better to Beg Forgiveness than to Ask Permission".
The thing that got me to move ahead with confidence
was one of my favorite quotes attributed to Goethe:
Whatever you can do, or dream you can, Begin it.
For Boldness has Genius, Power and Magic in it.
Begin it Now.
This was certainly a Dream, and it surely required Boldness, so when it was all ready to announce,
I sat down and wrote up a Press Release, and slipped a few copies in the mail to the media.
The first to bite was XETV, a San Diego run station transmitting from a tower in Tijuana, Mexico.
They called
me in to do an on-camera interview and it aired that same night. The rest, as they say, is history.
The storyline was about this relatively young computer guy (me!) who invents this free public computer service you can use on
your phone. And about how it will change everything. I was off on a huge roller-coaster ride,
one of the biggest adventures of my life!
The next day the press was all over it, and the following day there
were TV interviews on the rest of the stations in the area. Once the press got hold of it, it went out over the
UPI news wire and was written up in newspapers throughout the US.
Click here to read one of the news articles.
My parents called to say I had finally made it into
their local paper (Philadelphia Inquirer). The fallout was even more interesting.
The Discovery Channel wanted to learn more
about how to use my new service as a way of doing interactive TV.
They invited me to a think tank in Maryland to
join with some other brains to think new thoughts on the convergence of TV and computers.
Everyone wanted to see the computer. But I wouldn't allow it. It had to remain a mystery. If they ever saw
my butt-ugly stack of cheap hardware with tangled wires everywhere, they wouldn't believe their eyes. They would,
every one of them, expect to see something much larger. They would expect that a machine that would handle
the inquiries a million San Diegans to be a giant. If they saw it, it would be trivialized. Competitors
could get greedy thoughts. It would be best if the computer stayed a mystery.
Soon enough it wasn't news anymore. We had to prove ourselves. Before we announced the service, it was easy to sell
on the come. After the service was turned on, then we became real and advertisers wanted real numbers so they
could make intelligent decisions about the keywords and zip codes they should buy. It completely changed
the dynamic of selling.
The nail in the coffin for PAL was my partner Dave.
When he saw that he would have to invest real (serious) money, he
bailed out. Abruptly. I was left with a brand new startup with a bad case of "Cashus Interruptus".
I had to pay rent and payroll and suppliers... and what the heck was I going to do?
It was a long, slow, painful time for PAL. I moved him out of his office and into my spare bedroom, and only had
one phone line, but he was alive to the world, and living to serve. Soon the vultures appeared. A guy
from out of nowhere, Joe Labert, shows up and
figures he can get the money needed to get going again. He brings in Jimmy Geiger. Joe and Jimmy sold motor homes
together at La Mesa RV, a motorhome dealer.
Jimmy knows a guy in Mexico with more money than God, and he can get us
a shot at presenting the idea, but if this thing happens then it will be equal shares for Joe, Jimmy and me, and the
other 51% for the guy from Mexico. That dropped me from 100% of the company to 16%, but I was shark bait,
and there was no way I could resist.
When we showed up in Mexico City, and as we were ushered into an office, Max (the Money Man) came rushing by, and announced that his brother
had just had a heart problem in Houston and Max was leaving on his jet to go there now, but that he had about 20
minutes to learn about this new business he had heard about. This was devastating! I was told that I would have
meetings over 4 days to go into detail about this fantastic, global business that would soon change the world.
Instead of 4 days, I had 20 minutes. I talked like a man possessed of his subject, passionate and knowledgeable,
and as convincinly as one who had kissed the Blarney stone. At the end of 20 minutes, Max makes a move to get up, and I go in for the
close immediately, extending my hand: "So, Max, partners?" He shook my hand and we had a deal. PAL would live again. But the
adventure would become very strange indeed.
Max poured a ton of money into the business, and we learned a lot along the way.
For example: when people can anonymously request anything they can think of, just by keying it in on their
telephone, what would you expect would be the top two things they want? Did you say Food and Sex?
Well, to be more specific, it is Pizza and Topless Bars. Can you imagine the kind of demographic information
we could gather, by Zip Code? It was fantastic!
But even the best business idea the world has ever seen (am I being a bit un-humble here?) can still go
horribly awry. A successful business needs a lot more than a great idea. And I learned that lesson
the hard way...
Instead of going into some of the gory details of the devolution of PAL into nothingness,
let's simply say that it devolved. From that same nothingness sprang the vision of what became, 15 years later,
what we now call the internet, Google, Amazon, Facebook and more...
|